What About the “Other Woman”?

When a pastor falls, he leaves a wake of destruction behind. He hurts his church, his wife and family, and many others. When I blog, I often hear from many people who have been hurt, but I get a surprising number of emails from the women who were involved with the pastor – they often call themselves, “the other woman.” You know, the mistress. So, what about the “other woman”?

I’ve never liked any of those terms. I guess it’s because I was a pastor and married the woman I had an affair with. I could say, “We shouldn’t tag people with names according to their sin.” But I’d be a hypocrite since the name of my blog is “fallen pastor.” That, and Scripture accordingly tags us according to the sins we are habitually committing – “murderer, liar, etc.”

What About the "Other Woman"?When we use terms to describe people, we are speaking of their sin. When we start speaking of people, we begin to take the role of judge. When we speak of an “adulterer” to describe the person’s sin, we should always remember that there is hope for that person to repent and turn to Christ. When they do, they’re no longer an adulterer in God’s eyes, they are a forgiven person, cleansed by the righteousness of Christ.

With that said, what are we to think of “the other woman”?

Let me begin by telling you about what the relationship looks like before the pastor and the other woman get caught. He’s told her that he’s never met anyone like her. He’s told her that she listens to him and his wife doesn’t. He’s told her that he wants to leave his church and family for her. He has pledged his undying love for her. He may actually feel that way or he may just think he feels that way. Either way, they are in their own world of forbidden love.

Then, they get caught. Next, one of two things usually happen if the pastor doesn’t leave his family for her.

First, the pastor gets caught and tells the church leadership that it wasn’t a physical affair or as serious as it looks in order to save his family and ministry.

He tells the church leaders everything they want to hear so he can save some face. In doing so, the leadership demand he stops seeing her.When this happens, the leadership will tell him to sever all contact with her and often, the leaders will contact her (especially if she’s a staff or church member) and tell her to leave the church. They will tell her to never step foot in the church again.

She might be asked to tell her story, but usually, she doesn’t have the chance. Eventually, the story is passed around and the pastor’s version of events are told and the membership gets mad at her for “seducing” the pastor.

The second thing that happens is that the pastor falls and tells the church leadership and his wife everything.

As in the first case, the leadership tells him to stop contacting her, they ask her to leave and the pastor repents and attempts to reconcile with his wife.  In just a few cases I’ve seen over the years, churches have reached out to the “other woman” to help her. But I’ve only seen that in about two cases in 600.

Let’s be clear. Both the pastor and this woman have sinned. Both have committed adultery. Both are guilty of the sin. In just about every case I’ve seen, the pastor had a higher moral responsibility to stop the situation from going anywhere. But often, when the sin comes to the surface, it’s easier to place the blame on the “temptress.” I think that this is a very unfair balance for several reasons.

First, there is a moral failure within every human heart that only Christ can address. When we open ourselves to the possibility of sin, stop actively seeking Christ, and cease fellowship with believers of like mind, our hearts begin to wander. When our hearts wander, our actions aren’t too far behind.

Second, when moral failure occurs within the church, all aspects need to be addressed. Attempting to restore (or ignore the sins of) a pastor while sending out another member of the faith is inconsistent with our call to restore any of those within our fellowship (Galatians 6:1). Of course, the call to restore should be consistent with the desire for repentance on the part of those who sin. But when a person is cast out without even the offer of help, counseling, or guidance, the restoration cannot even begin.

Third, when “the other woman” is cast out, despite her sin, she is in the midst of confusion and needs a tremendous amount of support. Yes, she has sinned greatly. Yes, she has dug her own hole. Yes, she has committed adultery with the pastor. But at the moment of the fallout, how should the community of faith respond to her?

What are we to think of “the other woman”?

One of the most painful things for the church is that this woman has taken away the pastor who has led them and loved them for a long time. It’s hard for many people to feel anything but angst for the person who by their actions, took away their spiritual leader and hurt the pastor’s wife. So, it’s understandable if they don’t want to restore such a person to Christ. It’s understandable if the church leadership just wants to put her away from their sight.

But this is what makes the community of faith different, isn’t it? I’ve spoken with a What About the "Other Woman"?lot of “other women” who have said, “the pastor told me he loved me. He said he would leave his wife for me. He said we would be together forever. When we got caught, the leadership got so mean and told me to leave. People started gossiping and people who were once my friends are now acting terribly.”

I get what’s behind the church’s actions and feelings. Hurt. Anger. I understand that the church membership and leaders are in a precocious position.

That’s when we have to ask what the Christ-like response would be. What are we to do when it’s hard to love? What are we to do when we are hurt by others in the worst possible way? How are we to respond when we are betrayed by someone we thought was a friend?

Christ knew the answer and lived it. He was betrayed several times and in horrible ways and forgave freely.

Now, our forgiveness might take longer to digest and actualize, but it’s something worthwhile to work toward. In the meantime, if we are part of a community of faith, we need to view “the other woman” as a fallen person, like we are. A person created in the image of God, like us. Someone worth fighting for, worth saving, worth restoration. A person who has fallen as far as they can and who needs the hand of a fellow believer.

We are to reach out to any sinner, just as Christ did, in an attempt to restore them to fellowship.

And if we aren’t in a position at that moment to provide that hand, we have to be willing to find someone who can until we can open the door far enough to begin the process of forgiveness and restoration.

Other articles:

Forgiving the Other Woman” by Rebeca Seitz, from Crosswalk.com

Questions About Affairs From The Other Woman by Anne Bercht” – these are letters a Christian seminar group gets from “other women.” It’s an insight to the problems they suffer and they’re just like the problems we hear about, showing that these women need help.


Ray Carroll is the author of “Fallen Pastor: Finding Restoration in a Broken World,” which answers many of the questions I get asked on a weekly basis.

If you are a fallen pastor who needs to talk or you are someone who has been affected by a fallen pastor and would like to contact me privately, please click here. You are the main reason this ministry exists. I’m here to help you.

If you are a church, men’s group, association, conference, or news outlet and would like more information about this ministry, please click here.


Share this

4 thoughts on “What About the “Other Woman”?”

  1. As I was reading this article, the following section concerned me:

    “What are we to think of “the other woman”?

    One of the most painful things for the church is that this woman has taken away the pastor who has led them and loved them for a long time. It’s hard for many people to feel anything but angst for the person who by their actions, took away their spiritual leader and hurt the pastor’s wife. So, it’s understandable if they don’t want to restore such a person to Christ. It’s understandable if the church leadership just wants to put her away from their sight.”

    You state, “…this woman has taken away the pastor…” and “…the person who by their actions, took away their spiritual leader…” I must emphatically and respectfully disagree with these statements. The pastor took himself away; the pastor disqualified himself.

    Possibly, these statements were made to reflect the way some congregants processed the situation. If so, that is understandable, as there is certainly an initial emotional reaction and the need to place blame, although not necessarily based in reality.

      1. Thank you for your clarification. Having read the beginning of your article, where you speak about the pastor professing his love for the “other woman,” his desire to be with her, etc., this section confused me a bit, so instead of assuming what you meant, I asked.

        I speak as the “other woman,” because I am her. I was told these things by my pastor. I believed that he loved me, and I believed that I loved him. After discovery of our affair and his removal as pastor, I placed upon myself guilt that was not mine to carry. I knew some people would view me as the “temptress,” and quite frankly, I am sure some still view me in that way. If I am honest, it is easy for me to talk about being forgiven by God, that God has redeemed and is restoring me, and while I am largely able to walk in those truths, the guilt and shame is still able to paralyze within moments of a trigger.

        1. I’m sorry you’ve been in that situation. I have talked to many women in your situation and that’s why I write about it. There’s very little help out there for women in your situation and I hope one day that changes. Take care.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *